Mortgage Insurance vs Homeowners Insurance. Main Difference

Mortgage Insurance vs Homeowners Insurance

Updated - 2022.01.17

If you’re planning to buy a home, you might have come across many mortgage insurance and insurance for home loans. While both play an essential role in protecting your home or property, they are different. To help you make an informed choice, we have discussed the difference between mortgage insurance vs homeowners insurance.

These free online calculators can help you find out how much your monthly payment will be:

Mortgage Insurance – All You Need to Know

Mortgage Insurance vs Homeowners Insurance

Mortgage insurance is responsible for lowering the risks involved when a lender loans you. It helps you qualify for loans that, generally, you wouldn’t get. However, while it reduces the risk, giving you access, you also get an increased loan cost.

When you make a downpayment of less than 20% of the total amount for your home, you will have to service mortgage insurance. It is necessary even when you apply for USDA and FHA loans. When you are obligated to pay for mortgage insurance, the set amount will be added to the monthly payments you make to the lender. It may also be part of the closing cost.

More on Mortgage Insurance

Mortgage insurance, also called PMI, protects the lender and not you- the borrower if you do not honor your obligations. When you fail to make your loan payment, you risk losing your home, and you may also hurt your credit rating. However, the good news is that you may not be required to pay for PMI if the loan you get doesn’t want the 20% down payment.

You can access different types of loans if you cannot pay the 20% down payment.  These loans include:

Conventional Loan

When you receive a conventional loan, the lending institution arranges mortgage insurance through a private company. 

US Department of Agriculture (USDA) Loan

The US Department of Agriculture also issues loans. When you get their loan, you usually pay mortgage insurance and your monthly installments at closing.

Federal Housing Administration (FHA) Loan

This loan is often more expensive compared to USDA. However, when you get an FHA loan with them, they require you to pay them the mortgage insurance premiums.

Department of Veterans Affairs (VA)-backed loan

Getting a loan with the Department of Veterans’ Affairs backing takes the place of mortgage insurance, but they share the same functionalities. The VA-backed loans are loans for helping veterans, service members, together with their families. They do not require you to pay a mortgage insurance premium every month.

Understanding Homeowners Insurance

Lenders need homebuyers to pay a minimum of “hazard insurance,” which is included in a regular homeowners insurance plan. They pay for it before finalizing a mortgage. Unintended damage or devastation caused by smoke, fire, hail, wind, theft, burglary, or some other similar catastrophe is covered when you pay for hazard insurance.

However, it’s advisable to purchase comprehensive homeowners insurance to safeguard your interests, including liability insurance and more comprehensive hazard protection than your lending institution demands.

What does Homeowners Insurance Cover?

Apart from the housing cover you get, the homeowners’ insurance plan covers furnishings in your home together with your items and any additional structures put in your property. These could include your swimming pools or a separate garage. 

Hazard coverage on most plans excludes commercial equipment, natural disaster damage, and loss of artwork or jewelry valued at more than a specific amount. If you live in a risky location facing fires, earthquakes, floods, or other natural catastrophes, or if you have valuable art, jewelry, or office equipment at home, you’ll want to obtain supplementary insurance.

Mortgage Insurance vs Homeowners Insurance: Main Difference

As we’ve already established, mortgage insurance vs homeowners insurance are two similar but different products. They are different in terms of how they work. You may need them or not, depending on your situation.

Based on whether you can or cannot make the required down payment, you wouldn’t have a say in whether to pay or not to pay private mortgage insurance. Because PMI protects the lending institution, it will be best to avoid it if possible.

Mortgage protection insurance (MPI) covers you if you can’t make your mortgage loan payment. However, there are some restrictions: MPI only kicks in under certain circumstances, like unemployment, incapacity, or death. In most cases, this type of coverage is optional.

Homeowners insurance, unlike MPI and PMI, seems like a typical policy. It safeguards your property and belongings from environmental and man-made disasters. If your property is destroyed by fire, invaded, or seriously damaged by a hailstorm, your homeowner’s insurance covers the cost of repairing or rebuilding it. Creditors need home insurance if you have credit, but it is still a wise investment even if you already own your home outright.

Who and What Mortgage Insurance and Homeowners Insurance Cover

Mortgage Insurance and Homeowners Insurance

Homeowners insurance protects your property and personal belongings financially.

You are effectively paying to protect your property with everything in it from unfavorable events specified by the plan by making your monthly premium payments to an insurance provider. At the same time, homeowners insurance protects the lending institution’s financial interests. They stand to benefit when your home gets damaged during a natural disaster, and you can’t honor your obligations.

The homeowners insurance offers you these four kinds of cover:

  • Dwelling coverage: Covers the home’s structure when destroyed by elements like hail or wind.
  • Personal property coverage: Protects the contents of your home and also your personal items
  • Liability coverage: Protects you and the family members from litigation
  • Additional living expenses coverage: covers living costs if you are forced to live somewhere other than your home for a while

The homeowners insurance plan only extends the types of coverage to a limited level. For instance, it will only cover “perils” depending on the plan you pay for.

Mortgage insurance protects a mortgage company financially against the possibility of a borrower defaulting on the loan.

Mortgage insurance only covers the lender’s resource: the settlement of the loan, while homeowners insurance covers both the debtor and, consequently, the lending institution’s assets.

Mortgage Insurance vs Homeowners Insurance Costs

Mortgage Insurance vs Homeowners Insurance

Actual mortgage insurance costs will revolve around many factors, including the size of your down payment, your credit score, and the type of loan. However, home insurance costs can also vary by state, with average prices ranging from $1,211 to $3,039.

Most mortgage insurance rates cost approximately 0.5 percent and 5 percent of the initial cost of the mortgage loan annually, irrespective of the home’s valuation.

The overall average yearly value of home insurance as of 2018 (the most recent information available from the NAIC report for 2021) was $1,249, but categorizing rates by the dwelling coverage you choose can give you a better estimate of what you’ll pay.

Requirements to Avoid Mortgage Insurance

You can employ two strategies when you do not want to pay mortgage insurance:

Give a 20% Downpayment

Not everyone can save up to a 20% down payment. And it will take years for some people to get the percentage required, thus pushing their dreams further. But if you can, this will do you a lot of good.

Federal Housing Administration

The FHA program is one that you’d want to explore if you don’t want to avoid mortgage insurance. Its down payment rate is 3.5%, the upfront premium is 1.75%. Using this alternative helps you cut your down payment by half the amount.

Mortgage Calculator » Mortgage Insurance vs Homeowners Insurance. Main Difference
Mortgage Calculator GURU
Logo